From Passion to Purpose: Creating a Value Proposition

Why a Value Proposition Matters

A value proposition is more than a mission statement—it’s a promise. It explains why someone should engage with your organization and what unique benefit you offer. As the Harvard Business School blog emphasizes, an effective value proposition should be clear, specific, and targeted. It needs to answer the critical question: Why you?

As I dove into research, I realized just how vital this was—not only for potential donors and adopters but also for volunteers, advocates, and even the dogs we serve.

How to Write a Strong Value Proposition

The process of writing a value proposition begins with truly understanding the people you’re trying to reach. Who are they? What do they care about? What problems are they facing—and how does your organization offer a solution? According to Salesforce’s guide to customer value propositions, this clarity only comes from empathy and insight. It’s not about listing features—it’s about identifying the transformation you offer.

Once you understand your audience, the next step is to articulate your promise in a way that’s compelling, concise, and emotionally resonant. As Help Scout’s examples illustrate, the best value propositions don’t bury the lead. They use plain language, speak to the heart, and often paint a before-and-after picture. This is especially important in the nonprofit world, where you’re not just offering a product—you’re inviting people into a mission.

I found it helpful to begin with a longer version, breaking down exactly what we do for each key audience. Then, once I had a strong foundation, I refined it down to a shorter message that would be easier to share and remember. This exercise helped me not just clarify my message—but also reconnect with why I started this nonprofit in the first place.

Where I Started

I began by outlining a detailed value proposition that spoke to four key audiences we hope to serve:

---

The Frosted Face Foundation will be a senior dog sanctuary dedicated to providing love, comfort, and lifelong care to senior dogs who are often overlooked due to age or medical conditions. Our value proposition will speak uniquely to four key groups:

Forever Foster & Adoptive Families
We will offer the opportunity to transform a dog’s final chapter—without the financial burden. Forever Fosters will receive ongoing veterinary care and support while welcoming a loving companion into their homes. For adopters of healthier seniors, we will provide transparent medical histories, behavioral insights, and continued guidance.

Donors & Supporters
Your contributions will have an immediate, visible impact—funding vet visits, prescription medications, orthopedic beds, and comforting final days for senior dogs who would otherwise be euthanized or forgotten in shelters. Donors will be kept connected to the mission through heartfelt stories, photos, and updates on the dogs they help save.

Volunteers
Volunteers will have the opportunity to engage in meaningful, hands-on work with sweet senior pups who truly need them. Whether through dog walking, event support, or administrative help, volunteers will become part of a mission-driven community filled with gratitude, wagging tails, and purpose.

Advocates & Educators
We will partner with pet professionals, educators, and content creators to spread the word about the needs of senior dogs—redefining aging pets as wise, loving, and deeply deserving. Advocates will help rewrite the narrative around “unadoptable” dogs, one story at a time.

---

While this comprehensive version helped me think deeply about our audience and their needs, I realized that I needed something shorter—something that could serve as a concise, powerful introduction across platforms.

The Refined Version

After refining the message and focusing on clarity and emotional connection, I landed on the following:

The Frosted Face Foundation – Grey Muzzles. Golden Hearts.

The Frosted Face Foundation will be a safe haven for senior dogs who have lived their lives as loving, loyal companions who still have so much to give. Through our Forever Foster program, we’ll place these deserving dogs with families who see their value, while covering all medical care for life. With the support of a compassionate community, we’ll ensure every frosted face finds connection, comfort, and a place to call home.

This version feels true to the mission and is simple enough to be used anywhere—from an elevator pitch to a fundraising campaign.

What I Took Away

Writing a solid value proposition taught me that clarity is kindness. By taking the time to articulate who we serve, how we do it, and why it matters, I’ve created a foundation that not only guides our messaging—it inspires connection. Whether someone is donating, fostering, volunteering, or advocating, they’ll know exactly how they fit into our story.